Quick answer: A direct primary care physician is not automatically required to opt out of Medicare. Opting out matters when you want to treat Medicare beneficiaries for Medicare-covered services under a private arrangement instead of Medicare's rules. If you do, the choice covers all of your Medicare patients and all covered services, and it requires a signed affidavit filed with your Medicare Administrative Contractor plus a separate private contract with each beneficiary. A DPC membership agreement alone is not the Medicare private contract.
Many physicians hear that "DPC doctors have to opt out." In my work with direct primary care and concierge practices, I find it more useful to start with a different question: how will this practice serve Medicare patients? The answer shapes your fee, your documents and your other professional work, so I recommend settling it before you accept a membership payment from anyone on Medicare.
What are your options for Medicare patients?
Most DPC physicians face four common practice-planning scenarios. These are not four distinct Medicare legal statuses: the first and third both involve not furnishing covered services to Medicare beneficiaries in the DPC practice, but the third highlights obligations from other professional work. Review each scenario against your actual services and contracts.
- Do not treat Medicare beneficiaries for covered services. You then have no private contracts to manage, but you need a plan for what happens when a current member turns 65 or enrolls in Medicare.
- Stay in Medicare and follow its billing rules. Medicare does not cover membership fees. Doctors who accept assignment cannot charge extra for Medicare-covered services, and doctors who do not accept assignment are subject to a 15% limiting charge. All Medicare doctors may charge for items and services Medicare does not cover. Medicare.gov: Concierge care
- Stay in Medicare but do not treat Medicare beneficiaries for covered services. This scenario arises when a physician wants a private-pay DPC practice but needs to remain in Medicare for other professional work. An employment, group or moonlighting agreement may contractually restrict opting out or make it impractical. That is not a separate Medicare legal status or permission to charge Medicare beneficiaries privately for covered services without following Medicare's rules. The physician needs a plan not to furnish those covered services to Medicare beneficiaries in the DPC practice while meeting obligations elsewhere.
- Opt out and use private contracts. Medicare then pays nothing for your services, apart from the narrow emergency and urgent care rule below, and your Medicare patients pay you directly.
Is simply not billing Medicare the same as opting out?
No. Opting out is a formal process with its own federal requirements. Calling a practice "cash only" or leaving Medicare claims unfiled does not accomplish it. The ordinary mandatory claim submission requirement no longer applies to services furnished under a properly effective opt-out and compliant private contract, subject to the emergency and urgent care exception. Signing or filing an affidavit alone is not enough if the opt-out is not yet effective or other requirements have not been met. 42 CFR §§ 405.410, 405.425. CMS Medicare Benefit Policy Manual, Chapter 15, § 40
Can you opt out for only some patients?
No. CMS states that a physician "cannot choose to opt-out of Medicare for some Medicare beneficiaries but not others; or for some services but not others." Opting out also applies to the individual physician, wherever that physician furnishes care. A practice cannot make the election for everyone with one document, and each clinician's status needs its own review.
What does an opt-out change beyond your DPC practice?
Because the election follows you, review your other work before you file. This is the point I would look at first if you plan to keep a hospital, urgent care or group position while your practice grows.
- Other employers and groups: A group or other organization can no longer bill Medicare for the Medicare services you personally furnish. It can still bill for clinicians who have not opted out.
- Medicare Advantage: Plans make no payment for your Medicare-covered services, apart from qualifying emergency or urgent care.
- Existing participation: If you signed a Part B participation agreement, it ends on the effective date of your affidavit. 42 CFR § 405.420
- Orders and referrals: Your patients are not necessarily cut off from Medicare for everything. Medicare can pay for covered, medically necessary services you order or certify, such as lab work or a hospital stay, if the conditions CMS lists are met and another opted-out clinician does not furnish them. Eligible opted-out physicians may still order, certify, prescribe and refer for Medicare-covered items and services, subject to applicable requirements, including a valid NPI. Exclusion from Medicare or revocation of enrollment can affect that authority. As a practical step, confirm your ordering and referring status in the MAC's records and review any confirmation letter rather than assuming the letter grants that authority. 42 CFR § 405.425(i)–(j).
What must the opt-out affidavit say and when is it due?
The affidavit must be in writing, signed and include your identifying information and the commitments listed in 42 CFR § 405.420. Timing depends on your current status under 42 CFR § 405.410:
- Nonparticipating physician: File within 10 days after you sign your first private contract. Filed on time, the two-year period starts on the date you signed the affidavit. Filed late, it starts when the last required affidavit is filed, and services you furnished before then fall under ordinary Medicare rules. I advise physicians to address the opt-out filing before signing patient contracts so they are not scrambling to meet the 10-day filing deadline. Confirm the effective date and have a compliant private contract in place before furnishing Medicare-covered services on a private-pay basis. Filing alone does not make an opt-out immediately effective in every case.
- Participating physician: The opt-out takes effect at the start of a calendar quarter, and you must submit the affidavit at least 30 days before that quarter begins. Services before then fall under ordinary Medicare rules.
- More than one contractor: File with each Medicare Administrative Contractor you would otherwise bill. A physician working across South Carolina, Georgia and Ohio should confirm which contractors apply. CMS: Who are the MACs
What must the private contract include?
The private contract is a separate federal requirement. Under 42 CFR § 405.415, it must be in writing, in print large enough for the beneficiary to read, and signed by both sides before you furnish services. It must also:
- State whether you are excluded from Medicare;
- Say the beneficiary accepts full responsibility for payment and understands Medicare limits do not apply to your charges;
- Say the beneficiary agrees not to submit a Medicare claim or ask you to submit one;
- Say Medicare will not pay for your items or services under the contract;
- Say the beneficiary has the right to get Medicare-covered care from clinicians who have not opted out and is not required to sign a private contract to get other covered services;
- Give the expected or known start and end dates of the current two-year opt-out period; and
- Say Medigap plans do not pay, and other supplemental plans may choose not to pay, for these services.
The beneficiary receives a copy before services begin. You keep the original for the full two-year period and make it available to CMS on request. A contract cannot be signed while the beneficiary needs emergency or urgent care.
How does emergency or urgent care work after you opt out?
If you have no private contract with the beneficiary, you can still treat an emergency or urgent condition. You must submit a claim to Medicare and cannot charge more than the Medicare limiting charge. If you signed a private contract before the condition began, the contract's terms apply. 42 CFR § 405.440
Tell your staff how this works so a Medicare patient is not handed a private contract in the middle of an urgent visit.
How long does an opt-out last, and can you undo it?
An opt-out runs in two-year periods. Affidavits filed on or after June 16, 2015 renew automatically, so calendar the date. To stop a renewal, notify each contractor in writing at least 30 days before the current period ends. 42 CFR § 405.445 Private contracts are different: one must be entered into for each two-year period. 42 CFR § 405.415
A physician who has not opted out before may end the initial opt-out early by notifying every contractor within 90 days of its effective date. You must also refund amounts collected above the Medicare limiting charge and tell your contracted patients about the termination and their right to have claims filed. Outside that window, plan on the full two years.
What can void an opt-out?
The two main risks are a defective start and a lapse along the way.
- Failing to opt out properly: If a contract signed before the affidavit was filed does not meet the requirements, or the affidavit is not submitted as required, the attempted opt-out and private contracts are nullified. You must submit Medicare claims for covered services, including services furnished under the nullified contracts. A nonparticipating physician is subject to Medicare limiting-charge rules; a participating physician is subject to the charge limits in the participation agreement. Other practitioners may collect only applicable deductible and coinsurance amounts. You may make another attempt to opt out properly. 42 CFR § 405.430
- Failing to maintain it: Knowingly and willfully submitting Medicare claims or receiving Medicare payment, except as permitted for emergency or urgent care, can constitute failure to maintain opt-out. Separate grounds include furnishing covered services without a compliant private contract, failing to follow emergency or urgent care billing rules, and failing to retain contracts or make them available to CMS. These failures can nullify the opt-out and contracts for the remainder of the period, require claim submission, restrict charges and Medicare payment, and prevent another opt-out until the period ends. Demonstrating good-faith corrective efforts within 45 days of the MAC's notice can avoid these consequences. If a violation is not discovered by the MAC during the two-year period in which it occurred, the consequences can apply retroactively from the first violation through that period's end unless the physician makes good-faith corrective efforts within 45 days of MAC notice or the physician's own discovery, whichever is earlier. Corrective efforts include appropriate refunds to beneficiaries who lacked private contracts. 42 CFR § 405.435
Hypothetical: a member turns 65
Suppose a physician runs a DPC practice with no Medicare patients and has never opted out. A longtime member turns 65, enrolls in Medicare and wants to keep paying the monthly fee. Nothing in the membership agreement answers the Medicare question. Before the next visit, the physician needs to decide which practice-planning scenario fits and establish a compliant arrangement, because continuing as usual could mean charging a Medicare beneficiary for covered services without a compliant arrangement. Making this decision while the practice is forming is much easier than making it patient by patient.
Checklist: what to bring to your Medicare review
- Your current Medicare status: enrolled or not, participating or nonparticipating
- Every position where you furnish care, including hospital, urgent care and group work
- How many current or expected patients are on Medicare or close to 65
- What the membership fee includes, service by service
- Your draft membership agreement and any draft private contract
- Each Medicare Administrative Contractor you would otherwise bill
- Your plan for emergency and urgent care visits
- Who will track contract signing, retention and the two-year renewal date
- Website, enrollment and front-desk wording about Medicare
This checklist prepares a conversation. It does not certify compliance or replace a review of your specific arrangement.
Common questions
Do direct primary care doctors have to opt out of Medicare?
Not automatically. Serving Medicare beneficiaries does not by itself require opting out. The question is how you will handle Medicare-covered services and fees for those patients, based on your services and your Medicare participation status.
Can I charge a DPC membership fee and also bill Medicare?
Be careful with this structure. Medicare.gov says doctors who accept assignment cannot charge extra for Medicare-covered services, and a membership fee generally cannot include additional charges for items or services Medicare usually covers. Each item in the fee should be classified before you charge it.
Can Medicare patients join a DPC practice?
They can, but the arrangement depends on your Medicare position. If you have opted out, each beneficiary needs a compliant private contract, and Medicare will not pay for your services under it.
Will my Medicare patients lose their other Medicare benefits?
A private contract covers services from the opted-out physician. The contract must state that the patient can still get Medicare-covered care from clinicians who have not opted out, and Medicare can still pay for covered services you order when CMS's conditions are met.
How can I check whether a physician has opted out?
CMS publishes an Opt Out Affidavits dataset with provider names, specialties, addresses and effective dates. Confirm any important detail with the Medicare Administrative Contractor.
Sources
Checked November 2, 2026.
- 42 CFR § 405.410, conditions for properly opting out
- 42 CFR § 405.415, requirements of the private contract
- 42 CFR § 405.420, requirements of the opt-out affidavit
- 42 CFR § 405.425, effects of opting out
- 42 CFR § 405.430, failure to properly opt out
- 42 CFR § 405.435, failure to maintain opt-out
- 42 CFR § 405.440, emergency and urgent care
- 42 CFR § 405.445, renewal and early termination
- CMS Medicare Benefit Policy Manual, Chapter 15, § 40
- Medicare.gov, Concierge care
- CMS, Opt Out Affidavits dataset
Discuss your Medicare plan
I work with physicians starting and running direct primary care, concierge and direct specialty care practices, including membership agreements, practice setup and the policies behind them. If you are deciding how your practice will serve Medicare patients, explore my healthcare legal services or request a consultation. Keep the first inquiry general and leave out patient information and confidential records. Related reading: Concierge Medicine Membership Agreements, Starting a Direct Primary Care Practice in South Carolina and Direct Primary Care and HSA Rules.
Serving South Carolina, Georgia, and Ohio.
General educational information, not legal advice. Current law and your particular arrangement determine the appropriate approach. Reading this article or contacting the firm does not create an attorney/client relationship.

