Quick answer: Direct primary care (DPC) and concierge medicine both charge patients a recurring membership fee, but the law often treats them differently. A DPC practice usually takes a periodic fee for a defined set of primary care services and does not bill insurance for them. A concierge practice often charges a membership fee and also bills insurance or Medicare for covered visits. Those payment and service details affect which state insurance provisions may apply, what Medicare allows you to charge, whether the HSA rules for DPC fit, and what your patient agreement must say.
The names matter less than the facts. I review what the fee buys, who pays for which services and how the practice actually bills, because a "DPC" or "concierge" label on a website does not decide the legal treatment. This article compares the two models on the points that most often change a physician's documents and launch plan.
How do direct primary care and concierge medicine compare legally?
| Question | Direct primary care (typical) | Concierge medicine (typical) | |---|---|---| | How the practice is paid | Periodic membership fee for listed primary care services | Membership fee, plus insurance or Medicare billing for covered services | | State insurance law | Some states have DPC provisions with specific conditions, such as Georgia and Ohio | DPC provisions may not fit a model that bills insurance; review separately | | Medicare | Decide how you will serve Medicare patients; opting out is one option, not an automatic requirement | If you stay in Medicare, the fee cannot include extra charges for services Medicare usually covers | | HSA rules for 2026 | Qualifying DPC arrangements have federal HSA rules, including a monthly fee threshold for contribution eligibility | Do not assume the DPC HSA rules fit a membership that also bills insurance | | Patient agreement | Services included, fee, renewal, termination and any required insurance statement | What the fee buys versus what is billed to insurance or Medicare, access promises, renewal and refunds |
These are typical patterns, not legal categories. Many practices use hybrid models, and the analysis follows your actual arrangement.
Does state insurance law treat the two models differently?
It can. Some states have provisions that place qualifying DPC agreements outside state insurance regulation, but only when the arrangement meets the statute's definitions and conditions. A model that bills insurance for the same services, as many concierge practices do, should not assume it fits.
- Georgia: O.C.G.A. § 33-7-2.1 defines a DPC practice with periodic fees and no third-party fee-for-service billing, and any per-visit charge must be less than the monthly equivalent of the periodic fee. It also requires a written, signed agreement with specific terms and an insurance disclosure. See my guide to starting a direct primary care practice in Georgia.
- Ohio: Ohio Revised Code § 3901.95 sets conditions for a DPC agreement to receive its specified treatment outside insurance regulation, including a prominent statement that the agreement is not health insurance. The treatment depends on meeting all of the listed conditions, not on using a DPC label. Ohio permits a third party to pay the agreed fees but prohibits the provider from charging or receiving fees beyond those prescribed in the agreement for its listed services. Third-party payment of a membership fee is not the same as separately billing insurance for an included service. See my guide to starting a direct primary care practice in Ohio.
- South Carolina: South Carolina H. 3966 proposed a provision on the insurance treatment of DPC agreements. As of November 10, 2026, the legislature's record shows no action since it was referred to committee in February 2025, so it is not law. See my guide to starting a direct primary care practice in South Carolina.
If your model sits between the two, for example a periodic fee plus insurance billing for some services, describe the payment flow to counsel in detail before relying on any state provision.
How does Medicare treat each model?
Medicare's own guidance says it does not cover concierge membership fees. Doctors who accept assignment cannot charge extra for Medicare-covered services, and a membership fee cannot include additional charges for items or services Medicare usually covers. For many physician services, nonparticipating doctors who do not accept assignment may charge up to 15% above the applicable nonparticipating Medicare-approved amount, subject to any stricter state limits. This limiting-charge rule is not permission to add a membership surcharge for covered services. All Medicare doctors may charge for items and services Medicare does not cover. Medicare.gov: Concierge care
- A concierge practice that stays in Medicare needs a clear line between membership benefits and Medicare-covered services, and its agreement should show that line. My article on concierge medicine membership agreements covers how to write it.
- A DPC practice must decide how it will serve Medicare patients. Serving a Medicare beneficiary does not automatically require opting out, but if you opt out, the decision generally applies across your Medicare patients and otherwise covered services, rather than patient by patient. Proper opt-out requires timely affidavits and compliant private contracts signed before services are furnished. Special rules apply to emergency or urgent care when no private contract is in place; you cannot enter into a private contract while the beneficiary needs such care. 42 CFR § 405.410 and § 405.415
Do the HSA rules apply to both?
The federal HSA changes that took effect January 1, 2026 address direct primary care service arrangements. For 2026, the exception that preserves an otherwise eligible individual's ability to contribute to an HSA generally requires aggregate DPC fees of no more than $150 per month for an individual, or $300 per month for an arrangement covering more than one person. These are membership-fee limits for preserving contribution eligibility, not limits on HSA contributions themselves. The federal definition requires primary care services provided by qualifying primary care practitioners, with a fixed periodic fee as the sole compensation for those services. It excludes procedures requiring general anesthesia, prescription drugs other than vaccines, and laboratory services not typically administered in an ambulatory primary care setting. Separate billing for services included in the arrangement, through insurance or otherwise, does not meet that definition. 26 U.S.C. § 223(c)(1)(E), (d)(2) and IRS Notice 2026-5, Part III, Section C
Those rules turn on the federal definition of a direct primary care arrangement, not on what a practice calls itself. A concierge membership that also bills insurance should not tell patients the DPC HSA rules apply without a review. See Direct Primary Care HSA Rules for 2026 and 2027.
Does HIPAA apply differently?
The question is the same for both models: is the practice a HIPAA covered entity? For a health care provider, that depends on whether it transmits health information electronically in connection with a transaction for which HHS has adopted a standard, such as an electronic insurance claim, either itself or through another entity acting on its behalf. A concierge practice that bills insurance electronically is more likely to be one. A DPC practice that never bills insurance is not automatically outside HIPAA either; its actual transactions, including those conducted on its behalf, still need review. Merely using an electronic health record, email or a vendor does not by itself establish covered-entity status. State confidentiality duties apply either way. See Does HIPAA Apply to Your Direct Primary Care or Cash-Pay Practice? and HHS: Covered entities
What about Direct Specialty Care?
Direct Specialty Care applies a membership or direct-pay model to specialty services. Do not assume a state DPC provision or the federal DPC HSA rules cover it. The federal HSA definition is expressly limited to qualifying primary care services and practitioners. State definitions differ: Georgia and Ohio use broader health-care-service language, so the DPC label alone does not resolve whether a specialty arrangement qualifies. Review the services, the fee and the billing model on their own terms before you describe a specialty membership to patients.
Which model fits your practice? Questions to settle first
- [ ] Which services does the membership fee cover, and which are billed separately?
- [ ] Will the practice bill any insurer or Medicare, and for which services?
- [ ] Which state are your patients in, and does that state have a DPC provision whose conditions you meet?
- [ ] How will you serve Medicare patients: no covered services, stay in Medicare, or opt out?
- [ ] Will you tell patients anything about HSA use, and does your arrangement support it?
- [ ] Is the practice a HIPAA covered entity, and which vendors handle patient information?
- [ ] Does your website, enrollment form and agreement describe the same model?
- [ ] For specialty care: which parts of the model differ from primary care?
This checklist prepares a conversation. It does not certify compliance or replace a review of your specific arrangement.
Common questions
What is the main legal difference between direct primary care and concierge medicine?
What the membership fee covers and how the practice is paid. A DPC practice usually relies on a periodic fee and does not bill insurance for the included services, while a concierge practice often charges a membership fee and also bills insurance or Medicare. That difference affects state insurance treatment, Medicare charges, HSA statements and the patient agreement.
Will Medicare pay for a concierge doctor?
Medicare does not cover the membership fee. It can still pay for covered services from a concierge doctor who is enrolled in Medicare, and that doctor's fee cannot include extra charges for services Medicare usually covers.
Is a concierge membership considered insurance?
That depends on state law and the arrangement's terms. State DPC provisions such as Georgia's and Ohio's apply only to agreements that meet their definitions, and a model that bills insurance should not assume it fits.
Can a practice offer both models?
Yes. Some practices offer a hybrid, such as a membership with some insurance billing. Hybrids need especially careful agreements, because the line between membership benefits and billed services must be clear to patients, payers and Medicare. Separating charges on paper is not enough if the practice collects twice for the same service. Review payer contracts as well as state DPC requirements, Medicare rules and the separate federal HSA definition; satisfying one does not establish compliance with the others.
Do I have to opt out of Medicare to run a DPC practice?
Not automatically. The decision depends on whether you will furnish Medicare-covered services to Medicare beneficiaries and how you want to be paid for them.
Does Direct Specialty Care follow the DPC rules?
Not automatically. The federal HSA rules are limited to qualifying primary care services and practitioners, while state DPC definitions vary and may use broader language. A specialty membership needs its own review under each applicable rule.
Sources
Reviewed November 10, 2026.
1. O.C.G.A. § 33-7-2.1, Georgia SB 18 (signed legislation) — https://gov.georgia.gov/document/signed-legislation/sb-18pdf/download 2. Ohio Revised Code § 3901.95 — https://codes.ohio.gov/ohio-revised-code/section-3901.95 3. South Carolina H. 3966, legislative record — https://www.scstatehouse.gov/billsearch.php?billnumbers=3966&session=126&summary=B 4. Medicare.gov, Concierge care — https://www.medicare.gov/coverage/concierge-care 5. 42 CFR § 405.410 and § 405.415, Medicare opt-out and private contracts — https://www.law.cornell.edu/cfr/text/42/405.410 6. 26 U.S.C. § 223, health savings accounts — https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/26/223 7. Treasury and IRS guidance on HSA changes under Public Law 119-21 — https://www.irs.gov/newsroom/treasury-irs-provide-guidance-on-new-tax-benefits-for-health-savings-account-participants-under-the-one-big-beautiful-bill 8. IRS Notice 2026-5, Part III, Section C, direct primary care service arrangements — https://www.irs.gov/pub/irs-drop/n-26-05.pdf 9. HHS, Covered entities and business associates — https://www.hhs.gov/hipaa/for-professionals/covered-entities/index.html
Choosing between direct primary care and concierge medicine?
I work with physicians starting and running direct primary care, concierge and Direct Specialty Care practices, including membership agreements, practice setup and the policies behind them. If you are deciding which model fits your practice, explore my healthcare legal services or request a free 30-minute consultation. Keep the first inquiry general and leave out patient information and confidential records.
Serving South Carolina, Georgia, and Ohio.
General educational information, not legal advice. Current law and your particular arrangement determine the appropriate approach. Reading this article or contacting the firm does not create an attorney/client relationship.

